Deer Lawsuit Dismissed From Court

by Shoshanna M. |

By Shoshanna McCollum

Photo By Marc Millman

Judge Sandra J. Feuerstein dismissed the lawsuit Friends of Animals filed last year against National Park Service (NPS), Fire Island National Seashore (FINS), and former FINS Superintendent Christopher Soller for their controversial White-tailed Deer Management Plan adopted on Dec. 31, 2015. The Darien, Connecticut-based animal rights advocacy organization claimed that the said plan did not adequately address non-lethal options to control the FINS deer population.

“While (the National Park Service) did not include a discussion of Plaintiff’s proposed ‘nonlethal alternative,’ as stated above, the fact remains that no statute or regulation required it to do so,” wrote Feuerstein in a statement released by the U.S. District Court in Central Islip, on Friday, July 27, according to Newsday.

“Of course we’re disappointed,” said Friends of Animals Assistant Legal Director Jennifer Best in a telephone interview with Fire Island News. “We are still evaluating whether or not we will appeal this decision.”

There is still another pending lawsuit against the deer management plan in which Animal Welfare Institute and Wildlife Preserves, Inc. have filed jointly as co-plaintiffs. Presently FINS has plans to begin culling the deer population at William Floyd Estate in Mastic Beach, as well as Fire Island proper as early as 2019.

About the Author
Shoshanna M.

Shoshanna M.

Shoshanna McCollum is editor of Fire Island News. Author of two books, and award-winning journalist for multiple Fire Island and South Shore Long Island publications since 2000, she resides year round on Fire Island with her husband and many cats.

Share this Article

Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joan Rashid
Joan Rashid
2 years ago

I recently learned that Staten Island has a successful male deer surgical sterilization policy with the goal of substantually reducing but not totally eliminating population in a humane manner. Population decreases gradually over a few years. Why can’t this be done on Fire Island.